Are the sources an AI gives you real?
Sometimes. AI assistants can cite things that do not exist, and they can cite real pages that do not say what the text claims. The second kind is harder to spot, because the link works.
Three ways an AI's source goes wrong
- Made up entirely. A study, report, audit or quote with a plausible title and author that no page anywhere mentions.
- Real, but it says something else. The page exists and is on the topic, but the number, date or conclusion in the text is not what the page says.
- Real, but about something narrower. The page states the fact for one year, place or group, and the text makes it general.
Signs a citation may be made up
- A very specific result ("a 2023 study in the Journal of …found 37% …") that a search for its key details does not find.
- A quote attributed to a named person that appears nowhere else.
- A report title that sounds right for the organisation but is not on its website.
- A link to a real site whose path does not exist.
None of these proves a source is fake; a search can miss things. They tell you where to look harder.
How to check one
Do not stop at "the link opens". Find the sentence's fact on the page, in the page's own words, and compare the details: the number, the date, who said it, and what it applies to. If you cannot find the passage, you do not have a source for that sentence yet.
It also helps to search for the fact without the AI's link. If the fact is real, other pages usually state it too, and you may find the original source the AI was summarising.
Checking many sentences at once
Ibid Check searches the web for each sentence on its own rather than following the links in the text, reads the pages it finds in full, and shows the exact passage that backs or contradicts the sentence. When it cannot find a page, or the page does not say it, it says so instead of guessing. Every passage it shows is checked to be on the page word for word. How it works.
Check a text